mutation-safety-spans-all-dimensions
OUT derived (depth 7)
Every mutation is safe along three orthogonal dimensions simultaneously: source dimension (human, LLM, or agent), semantic dimension (uniform revision via outlist defeat and backtracking), and lifecycle dimension (respects retraction state and propagation bounds) — no mutation path is exempt from any dimension.
Summary
The system guarantees that any change to the belief network is safe no matter who initiates it, what kind of revision it performs, or what state the affected nodes are in — and no path through the system gets to skip any of these checks. This is currently retracted because one of its supporting claims about uniform safety across all modification sources and lifecycle states no longer holds.
Justifications
SL — one covers source+semantic uniformity, the other covers lifecycle+source safety; combining closes the three-dimensional coverage
Antecedents (all must be IN):
- all-mutation-sources-are-safe-and-uniform — Every belief modification path — human-initiated dialectical challenge/defend, LLM-derived proposals, and multi-agent import/sync — is simultaneously operationally safe (atomic, bounded, deterministic) and semantically uniform (same outlist/disjunction evaluation, same edge-case handling), with no source-specific exceptions or special-case machinery at any level.
- revision-spans-lifecycle-and-all-sources — The revision system is safe across two orthogonal dimensions: node lifecycle (backtracking skips retracted nodes, propagation respects lifecycle states, challenge preserves semantics through irreversible transformation) and modification source (dialectical, LLM, multi-agent) — ensuring no revision path is unsafe regardless of the node's lifecycle state or the belief's origin.