revision-invariants-span-all-origins
OUT derived (depth 6)
Both revision paths (reactive contradiction resolution and proactive dialectical challenge) preserve system invariants across all belief origins — human, LLM, and agent — because invariant preservation flows from shared minimal foundations and all origins share the same deterministic revision engine.
Summary
The system's correctness guarantees hold uniformly no matter who contributes a claim — human, LLM, or autonomous agent — because every source feeds into the same deterministic revision engine built on shared primitives. This means no origin gets special treatment or can bypass the safeguards that keep the knowledge base consistent.
Justifications
SL — Shared minimal foundations guarantee invariant preservation (depth-5) while all origins share the same engine (depth-5); together they show invariants hold regardless of belief provenance
Antecedents (all must be IN):
- revision-invariants-follow-from-shared-foundations — Both revision paths (reactive contradiction resolution and proactive dialectical challenge) preserve system invariants not through path-specific correctness arguments but because they operate through the same minimal primitives — shared foundations guarantee that any revision entry point inherits the same invariant-preserving behavior.
- all-belief-origins-share-deterministic-revision — All belief origins — human-initiated dialectical challenges, LLM-derived proposals, and multi-agent imports — participate in the same deterministic revision system: dialectics receive deterministic evaluation through semantic transparency (no special-casing), while agent beliefs undergo full revision through the comprehensive minimal revision primitives — no belief source escapes uniform treatment.
Dependents
These beliefs depend on this one:
- external-integration-preserves-all-invariants — External beliefs are architecturally safe at ingestion and participate in the same invariant-preserving revision system as all other belief origins — architectural containment and revision parity together ensure external integration cannot corrupt system invariants.
- invariants-hold-across-origin-and-time — System invariants hold along every independent dimension: across all belief origins (human-initiated, LLM-derived, agent-imported) via shared minimal foundations, and across both temporal phases (creation-time edge-case handling and maintenance-time staleness detection) including all semantic edge cases.